Your S-corp reasonable compensation, your entity election, your whole tax structure — most owners set them up once and never look again. I asked a business owner a simple question last week: why are you set up as an S corp? She paused. Then she said: my CPA set it up years ago. I trust them. I have not really thought about it since.
Seven figures in revenue. Years in business. No idea whether the structure underneath it all still made sense. That is not unusual. Unfortunately, that is normal.
Here is the thing about your CPA. They are not your doctor. Your doctor schedules your annual. Your CPA calls when taxes are due.
But here is the thing about your doctor. They cannot save you if you show up once a year, nod at everything they say, and never ask a question on your way out the door. Your health requires something from you. So does your business structure.
Nobody is lying awake at night thinking about whether your S corp election still makes sense now that your revenue has doubled. Nobody is wondering whether your S-corp reasonable compensation is still defensible to the IRS. Nobody is asking whether the entity you set up in year three still fits the business you are running in year nine. That has to be you.
If you cannot answer these four questions right now, you have your answer.
Most business owners at your level cannot answer all four.
Of those four questions, the salary one carries the most risk. The IRS expects an S corp owner to pay themselves reasonable compensation for the work they actually do before taking distributions. Set that number too low and you invite scrutiny; set it without support and you cannot defend it. If your revenue has grown but your salary has not moved in years, your S-corp reasonable compensation may no longer hold up — and that is exactly the kind of thing an entity checkup catches.
Filing your taxes and reviewing your structure are not the same thing. A tax return looks backward. An entity checkup looks forward. It asks whether your legal and tax structure is still the right vehicle for where you are going — not just where you have been.
The best patients do not just show up. They prepare. They push until they understand the reason, not just the recommendation. They get a second opinion when something does not sit right.
Nobody is going to take your financial health more seriously than you. It is time to act like it.
Reasonable compensation is the salary the IRS expects an S corp shareholder-employee to pay themselves for the work they actually perform, before taking distributions. It should reflect what a comparable role would earn in the open market, supported by factors like duties, time, experience, and industry pay data.
Review it against where the business is now, not where it started. If your revenue, profit, ownership, or goals have changed materially since the entity was set up, it is worth confirming the S corp election still produces the best tax and legal outcome — a forward-looking entity checkup rather than a backward-looking tax return.
Yes. If the IRS believes an S corp owner took distributions while paying themselves an unreasonably low salary, it can reclassify distributions as wages and assess back payroll taxes, interest, and penalties. Documented, defensible reasonable compensation is the protection.
At least once a year, and any time something significant changes — a jump in revenue, a new owner or partner, a new line of business, a move to another state, or a shift in your long-term goals. Those are the events that should trigger a conversation with your CPA.
No. Filing a return records what already happened. Reviewing your structure asks whether your entity and compensation are still the right setup for where the business is heading. One looks backward; the other looks forward.
A meaningful change in revenue or profit, adding or removing an owner, launching a new product or service, hiring family members, expanding to a new state, or planning an exit. Any of these can change whether your current entity and reasonable compensation still fit.
Disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or accounting advice. Whether an S corp election and a given compensation level are appropriate depends on your specific facts and circumstances. Please consult a qualified tax professional before making changes to your entity structure or owner compensation.
Take a more proactive role in your own tax outcomes with these related guides: